Skip to content

For everyone

Comparing approaches: from Lidcombe to the Kassel programme

On this page

On this page

  1. How to read this overview
  2. The two main directions
  3. Programmes for children
  4. Programmes for teens and adults
  5. What the IVS is
  6. What the guideline does not recommend
  7. What to look for when choosing
  8. What you can take with you
  9. Sources

§ 00 · In short

An overview of well-known programmes and directions for children and adults and what sets them apart. No ranking and no promises.

How to read this overview

There are many names: Lidcombe, KIDS, Camperdown, Van Riper. This article sorts them. It does not rate them and does not tell you what to choose. Which method suits you or your child is something you work out with a speech and language therapy practice that has experience with stuttering. What the studies say is in the article "Approaches and what the studies say". The descriptions are kept short on purpose, and each programme has its own procedure. Some programmes are mainly used in Germany.

The two main directions

According to the German stuttering self-help association BVSS, two main directions have developed. Both have been studied scientifically and can be combined:

  • Fluency shaping (speech restructuring): You learn a changed way of speaking, for example a soft voice onset and linking syllables. It is used almost all the time and has to be practised regularly.
  • Stuttering modification: You learn to change and control a moment of stuttering, and you reduce avoidance and fear. Typical are block-release techniques such as pull-out. It is also called the non-avoidance approach or the Van Riper approach.
  • Combined approach: You learn both and choose according to the situation.

Programmes for children

  • Lidcombe Program: From Australia. Parents practise with their child in daily life under the guidance of a professional and give feedback on fluent speech. Mainly for preschool children. The programme is well studied. A Cochrane review still rates the certainty of the evidence for children up to six years as low to moderate.
  • KIDS: A concept widespread in German-speaking countries that involves the child and the parents. It was examined in the Innovation Fund of the Federal Joint Committee.
  • Mini-KIDS: The version of KIDS for younger children of preschool age.
  • Indirect approaches: The professional works with the parents to find out in which circumstances the child stutters more and changes the environment.

Programmes for teens and adults

  • Camperdown Program: Also from Australia, a fluency shaping programme with prolonged speech. A small study with 40 people also tested it by telehealth.
  • Kasseler Stottertherapie (Kassel stuttering therapy): An intensive programme for teens and adults that focuses on speech technique. Check the schedule, length and costs with the provider yourself.
  • Van Riper: The basis of stuttering modification. It includes pseudostuttering, post-block analysis and pull-out, among others.

What the IVS is

The IVS is the Interdisziplinäre Vereinigung der Stottertherapeuten (interdisciplinary association of stuttering therapists). It is not a method. It publishes guidelines on the professional and personal qualifications of practitioners. It helps with the question of how to recognise good professionals, and it runs a directory of stuttering therapists.

What the guideline does not recommend

According to the BVSS, the AWMF gives a negative recommendation for breathing techniques, hypnosis, natural medicine and similar offers. Be careful with promises such as "clinically proven" or "in a few days".

What to look for when choosing

  • Does the method fit your goals: stuttering less, stuttering more easily, less fear?
  • Is there aftercare? More in the article "Setbacks, aftercare and refreshers".
  • Do the professionals have experience with stuttering?
  • Individual or group, in person or online?
  • How long does it take, how much effort and what does it cost?

What you can take with you

  • Two main directions: change the way you speak or change the stuttering. A combination is possible.
  • For children up to six years, programmes such as Lidcombe and KIDS are widespread, always with the parents.
  • There is no method for everyone. Be sceptical of anyone who promises a sure result.
  • Sagbar does not replace speech and language therapy.

Sources

  1. BVSS: Stuttering therapy for children, teens and adults (methods; in German)
  2. AWMF: Guideline on fluency disorders (049-013; in German)
  3. Cochrane review CD013489: Medicine-free treatment for children aged six and younger
  4. Deutsches Ärzteblatt International 2017: Pathogenesis, Assessment and Treatment of Speech Fluency Disorders
  5. Interdisziplinäre Vereinigung der Stottertherapeuten (IVS): guidelines (in German)
  6. Kasseler Stottertherapie (in German)

This article does not replace speech-language therapy or medical advice. Find help

Back to overview