Skip to content

For everyone

Approaches and what the studies say

On this page

On this page

  1. First of all
  2. Children up to six years
  3. School-age children and teenagers
  4. Adults: two main directions
  5. Online and by video
  6. Anxiety and avoidance
  7. Aids: delayed auditory feedback (DAF)
  8. And apps?
  9. What you can take with you
  10. Sources

§ 00 · In short

Which approaches to treatment exist, what research shows about them and where it still has gaps. Honest and without promises.

First of all

This is about approaches to treatment, not about promises. There is no method that works for everyone. Anyone who claims otherwise deserves some skepticism. This article sums up what studies and professional texts say, and it names the gaps.

The German S3 guideline on speech fluency disorders dates from 2016 and is being revised. Some things may change.

Children up to six years

The best studied is the Lidcombe Program. Parents practise with their child in everyday life, under the guidance of a professional. A Cochrane review rates the certainty of the studies for children up to six years as only low to moderate, though.

In Germany the KIDS concept is also widespread. It was evaluated within the Innovation Fund of the Federal Joint Committee. Programs for young children belong in the hands of a speech and language therapist.

School-age children and teenagers

For this age group there are hardly any high-quality studies. There are hints that computer-based programs and the combination of cognitive behavioural work and speaking techniques can be helpful. The statements should be read with care.

Adults: two main directions

Speech restructuring (fluency shaping). You learn a changed way of speaking, for example with a soft voice onset and stretched syllables. Well-known programs are Camperdown and the Kassel stuttering therapy. For this direction there is the strongest evidence in adults when the aim is to stutter less. The price is that your speech sounds unfamiliar at first and that you need to practise regularly.

Stuttering modification. The aim is to stutter more easily and to be less afraid of it. Among other things you learn to let stuttering happen consciously and loosely (pseudostuttering), to analyse a stutter afterwards (post-block work) and to work your way out of a block (pull-out). This goes back to the therapist Charles Van Riper. Here research shows more effect on anxiety and attitude than on how often you stutter.

Both directions have their place. Which one suits you depends on your goals.

Online and by video

The Camperdown Program was tested via telehealth in a randomised study with 40 people. There it worked as well as treatment in person. A study with 40 people is small. The result is encouraging, but not yet proof.

An online program without a therapist showed an effect that depended on how much it was used. Sticking with it was the main difficulty.

Anxiety and avoidance

Cognitive behavioural work (CBT) improves mainly thoughts, attitude and anxiety, according to studies. It has hardly any influence on how fluent your speech is. Acceptance and commitment work (ACT) seems plausible, but so far relies mostly on expert opinion. Social anxiety is clearly more common in adults who stutter.

Aids: delayed auditory feedback (DAF)

You hear your voice with a short delay through headphones. For many people, speaking improves immediately. The effect usually disappears when the device is missing, though. DAF is therefore an aid, not a treatment.

And apps?

So far there are hardly any robust studies on apps for people who stutter. We know of no large randomised study of a stuttering app. There are small pilot studies. Advertising with "clinically proven" should make you suspicious. Sagbar promises no effect. It offers exercises based on approaches with evidence and wants to make sticking with it easier.

What you can take with you

  • For adults, speech restructuring has the strongest evidence for stuttering less.
  • Stuttering modification and CBT aim more at anxiety, avoidance and attitude.
  • For children, programs belong in professional hands. The evidence there is only moderately certain.
  • Whether something helps is individual. A speech and language therapist can help you choose. More in the article "Finding help".

Next up: Soft voice onset

Sources

  1. Cochrane review CD013489: Medicine-free treatment for stuttering in children aged six years and younger
  2. Baxter et al. 2015: UK HTA Stuttering Review
  3. Ärzteblatt International 2017: Pathogenesis, Assessment and Treatment of Speech Fluency Disorders
  4. Camperdown Program via telehealth: trial registry ISRCTN48954432
  5. Speech treatment vs. social anxiety treatment: Review 2021
  6. Delayed auditory feedback (DAF): review article
  7. AWMF: German S3 guideline on speech fluency disorders (049-013, 2016, expired, being revised)

This article does not replace speech-language therapy or medical advice. Find help

Back to overview